volume two · the nightshade compact · ordinance 1518
THE NIGHTSHADE COMPACT
The tomato is a nightshade. That is not a joke and it is not a metaphor — it is the family it is in, and it is in there with the potato, the pepper, the aubergine and the plant the family is named after.
the real family, stated plainly
Solanaceae is a family of flowering plants. Its members include the tomato, the potato, the pepper, the aubergine, the tobacco plant, the petunia — and Atropa belladonna, the deadly nightshade.
The tomato's leaf and stem carry tomatine and, like the potato's green parts, solanine. Those are why the leaves and the unripe green fruit were treated with caution in Europe for two centuries while the ripe fruit was eaten. The family resemblance is not decorative; it is chemistry, and it is why the plant spent its first two hundred years in Europe as an ornament.
The Bureau did not invent any of that. The Bureau merely refused to stop noticing it.
the reverse of the card
ordinance 1518 · the delivery schedule
What follows is the reverse of the index card found at the end of Volume One, transcribed. There is no prose on it. There is no signature on it either, which is the first thing that is wrong with it.
| # | line item | specification | status |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | The Root | for the ground — to be taken as food, freely, without question | delivered |
| 2 | The Leaf | for the poison — to be kept, and to be known to be kept | delivered |
| 3 | The Flower | for the resemblance — to be bought on appearance alone | delivered |
| 4 | The Skin | for the carrying — to hold, to travel, and not to mark | delivered |
| 5 | The Vessel | for the journey — to arrive anywhere, and to require nothing | outstanding |
| 6 | The Vehicle | edible · unsolicited · self-propagating | see note |
note on item 6 · do not eat
Countermanded. Item 6 is not among the items eaten. Item 6 is the item that does the arriving. It is issued in quantity, without a request, irreversibly, and its purpose is to travel. It has no other purpose. Any entry describing item 6 as food is an entry made by the recipient.
The Bureau's reading: five of the six items were delivered to be used. The sixth was delivered to be received, which is a different transaction, and nobody was asked.
the 1893 ruling, which is real
In 1893 the Supreme Court of the United States decided that a tomato is a vegetable — not because it is one in botany, but because of how it is used: served with the main course rather than as dessert. The tomato was the defendant. The tariff was the charge. The evidence was the menu.
The Bureau's interest is not the outcome. It is the method. A court was asked what a tomato is, and it answered by looking at the plate — which is the Bureau's method too, and the only one that has ever produced an honest answer about this fruit.
The Bureau is aware that this ruling is one hundred and thirty-three years old and does not bind a kitchen. The Bureau cites it because the tomato's defenders like to begin with botany, and botany was settled in the tomato's favour and changed nothing that anyone ate.
file 2012-P1 · the concession
The Bureau concedes one.
Pico de gallo is a dish genuinely made of tomato, and if you take the tomato out of it there is nothing left. One dish. The register says one. An argument with a concession in it cannot be dismissed.
