file 2013-P2 · the campaign

THE MENU PLEDGE

The Bureau has asked for one thing since 1998, and it is not a ban. It is a line.

A menu is a list of what is in the food. The tomato is not on it. The dish is described, the ingredients are named, the sauce is explained in a sentence nobody asked for — and the tomato, which will be the first thing you remove, goes unmentioned because it was never a decision. It was a habit, and habits do not get printed.

So the customer cannot see it coming. Which means the customer has to ask — in advance, out loud, in front of other people — for something that should have been on the page. Every member of this movement has had that conversation. It is always faintly embarrassing, it is always unnecessary, and it happens because of a missing line.

the pledge, as offered

T — contains tomato. Will be left off if you ask.

One mark and one line, on the menu. Not on the plate, not on the wrapper, and not in a speech from a server.

why a mark, and not a paragraph

A menu is not read, it is scanned, at the speed of hunger, and the eye is looking for a shape and a letter. One mark, in the same place on every line, and it is learned in a single visit.

And the second sentence is the important one. A mark by itself is a warning, and a warning by itself is what this movement is accused of wanting. "Will be left off if you ask" is the other half: it turns an announcement into an offer, and it does the one thing no sign can do. It tells the customer that asking is normal, expected, and already agreed to. It removes the argument before the argument starts.

what the pledge is not

The Bureau has had this conversation four hundred times, so it is written down here once.

  • It is not a ban. Nothing is removed from any kitchen.
  • It is not a warning. No health claim is made. The Bureau sells no position and gains nothing.
  • It is not a medical declaration, and it needs no note from anybody's doctor.
  • It is not a change to any recipe. Every dish is served exactly as it is served today, to everybody who wants it that way.
  • It is a list. It is the menu stating what is on the plate — which is what a menu is for.

the cost — where the argument becomes difficult to refuse

The tomato is the cheapest item in the kitchen. It is on the plate because it is nearly free, and it is removed by the customer for exactly the same reason.

So consider what the Bureau is actually asking for: a mark that lets the kitchen do less work, on an ingredient that costs less than the bread, for a customer who will pay the same price for less food.

The member who asks for no tomato is giving the restaurant a gift, and being thanked with a facial expression.

— The Bureau

The file contains the sentence, from a member, in 2005: "I always order with 'no tomatoes' and save the restaurant some money, and do they say thanks? No."

the first adopter — ninety days, and nothing happened

One restaurant — the one that had already confessed that the tomato is in the sandwich "because the sandwich looks empty without it" — agreed to print the pledge for one quarter. The Bureau sent a field officer for the full ninety days.

Nothing happened.

That is the finding, and it is the entire result:

  • no dish was altered;
  • not one customer ordered a tomato who would not have ordered one anyway;
  • two members a day said thank you;
  • the kitchen reported that the line saved time, because the request now arrives before the plate does;
  • and the tomato order at that location fell by a quantity the Bureau declines to publish, because it is about four tomatoes a week and the restaurant asked us not to.

the mark costs nothing, changes nothing, and is the whole demand. That is why the Bureau has been asking for it for twenty-seven years, and why the refusal is so strange. A restaurant that will reprint its entire menu for the season will not add one line to it.

file 2012-P1 · the concession

The Bureau concedes one.

Pico de gallo is a dish genuinely made of tomato, and if you take the tomato out of it there is nothing left. One dish. The register says one. An argument with a concession in it cannot be dismissed.