file 1999-C1 · the interview · the founding document

THE INTERVIEW

On the evening of 19 January 1999, a national Canadian radio network broadcast four minutes and fifty-four seconds about a man in Windsor, Ontario, and his website.

the recording

Four minutes and fifty-four seconds. There is a second, bleeped cut at /cbc/cbc_interview-bleeped.mp3.

what was said, and why it is not transcribed here

The Bureau describes the broadcast rather than reproducing it, and it does that for a reason the reader is entitled to know: four minutes of somebody else's broadcast belongs to somebody else. Play it from this page. It is not copied onto it.

The announcer opened with a confession of his own — that he had a food he could not abide, and that most people keep their aversions to themselves. Then he introduced the founder, used the word hate with a capital letter, and asked the question every member of this movement has been asked for twenty-seven years: what did these little red things ever do to you?

The answer was already complete, and it took one word.

"They're poisonous."

— The founder, 19 January 1999

Asked about the taste, the founder was careful. He said he had never tasted one, because of the smell. The announcer said he had never associated a smell with tomatoes at all — and the Bureau will put the answer the way it was put then, because it has not improved in twenty-seven years: a thing does not stop being poisonous because it seems ordinary to you. It had been accepted by everybody in the room. Acceptance is not evidence.

the complaint, which is the whole movement

In the same interview, in January 1999, came the complaint this project is about. He said what annoyed him was asking for no tomatoes and being given them anyway — and that by then it was already too late, because it had soaked into the bun and the seeds were everywhere else.

Twenty-seven years later that is still the finding. The tomato is not a matter of taste. It is a matter of a request that was not made and a decision that was taken anyway.

Which is why what the Bureau asks for is so small: one mark, and one line, on the menu.

file 2012-P1 · the concession

The Bureau concedes one.

Pico de gallo is a dish genuinely made of tomato, and if you take the tomato out of it there is nothing left. One dish. The register says one. An argument with a concession in it cannot be dismissed.