the garden · answered first, argued with second

TOMATO LEAVES TURNING YELLOW

Most of the time it is water — usually too much of it. Check the soil before you buy anything: if it is wet a few centimetres down, stop watering for a few days and see what happens. If it is dry and pulling away from the pot, water deeply and less often. Then work down the list below.

what to check, in the order it is worth checking

This is a list of possibilities, not a diagnosis. A web page cannot see your plant, and a page that pretends to is not worth reading.

check 1

Water — too much of it, almost always

The sign
Yellowing starts at the bottom and moves up; the soil stays wet below the surface; leaves feel limp rather than crisp.
What to do
Let the top few centimetres dry between waterings. Check that the pot or the row actually drains — a saucer full of water is a drowning, not a drink.

check 2

Water — not enough of it

The sign
Yellowing with dry, curling edges, and the soil pulling away from the side of the pot.
What to do
Water deeply and less often rather than a little every day. Deep watering makes roots go down; daily sprinkling makes them shallow and fragile.

check 3

Nitrogen running out

The sign
Pale yellow across the whole leaf, oldest leaves first, and a plant that has simply stopped growing.
What to do
Feed it. A tomato in a pot exhausts the compost it was planted in by midsummer, and no amount of water replaces what has been used up.

check 4

Magnesium running out

The sign
Yellow BETWEEN the veins while the veins stay green — the leaf looks like a map of itself.
What to do
This pattern is specific enough to act on. A magnesium feed is cheap and the answer is quick; if nothing changes in a fortnight, it was not magnesium.

check 5

Early blight

The sign
Brown spots with a yellow halo, on the lowest leaves first, spreading upward and outward.
What to do
Remove the affected leaves, bin them rather than compost them, and keep water off the foliage. Blight spreads by splash.

check 6

Root damage, cold, or a plant that is simply finished

The sign
Sudden yellowing after a cold night, after root disturbance, or late in the season when the fruit is already set.
What to do
Sometimes the honest answer is that the plant is done and the fruit will ripen off the vine. That is not a failure.

the one thing that is not about the leaves

Every cause above is ordinary horticulture, and the Bureau will not pretend otherwise. A tomato plant that is well watered, well fed and well aired goes green and sets fruit. That is what the plant does, and it is very good at it.

But notice what the list is actually about. Almost every entry is the plant telling you it has been given the wrong quantity of something — too much water, too little, too little food, too little air. The tomato is not a fragile plant. It is a plant that will not stop reporting.

Which is, if you are prepared to read it that way, the only crop in the garden that complains in the same language as this website. It goes yellow when it is unhappy. It says so on the leaf, in front of everybody, without being asked.

The Bureau has spent twenty-seven years arguing that the tomato should be requested. It has never argued that it should not be grown. Read the leaf, fix the water, and get your crop.

— The Bureau

The ask is only about the plate: one mark on a menu, one line under it. A plant in a pot is not the argument.

file 2012-P1 · the concession · pico de gallo

The Bureau concedes one.

Pico de gallo is a dish genuinely made of tomato, and if you take the tomato out of it there is nothing left. One dish. The register says one. An argument with a concession in it cannot be dismissed — and a movement that will not concede a leaf is a movement nobody should listen to.