the record · answered first, argued with second
FRUIT OR VEGETABLE?
Both. Botanically it is a fruit — a berry, and the seeds are on the inside, which is what makes it one. In a kitchen and in a shop it is a vegetable, because of how it is cooked and eaten. Neither answer is wrong, and the argument has been running for more than a hundred years.
the botany, which is not in dispute
In botany a fruit is the part of a flowering plant that develops from the ovary and carries the seeds. A tomato is exactly that. It is classified as a berry — a fleshy fruit with the seeds inside the flesh — and it sits in the nightshade family, which is its own file.
The botanical definition includes a great deal that nobody calls a fruit at dinner: a cucumber, a courgette, a pepper, a bean pod, and the tomato. That is not a loophole in the definition. It is what the word means to a botanist.
the kitchen, which is not in dispute either
In cookery, a fruit is something you eat as a fruit — sweet, raw, at the end of a meal or in the hand. A vegetable is what goes into the savoury part. A tomato goes with garlic, oil, salt and heat. Nobody has ever served one as dessert without a reason, and the reason was usually a bet.
So the two answers are answering two different questions, and both are correct, and the argument only exists because English uses one word for a plant part and another for a shopping aisle.
and then in 1893 a court was asked
In Nix et al. v. Hedden, Collector, 149 U.S. 304 (1893), the Supreme Court of the United States had to decide whether a tomato was a fruit or a vegetable. It was not a botanical question. It was a tariff question: vegetables carried a duty and fruits did not, and the money turned on the word.
The Court held that the tomato was a vegetable — and it did not do so by contradicting the botanists. It did so by looking at the plate:
…usually served at dinner in, with, or after the soup, fish, or meats which constitute the principal part of the repast, and not, like fruits generally, as dessert.
Read that again. A court was asked what a tomato is, and it answered by looking at how the tomato is served. Everything the Bureau has ever argued about this fruit is in that sentence, and it was arrived at by nine justices in 1893 by accident, in a case about import duty.
what the Bureau takes from it
The tomato is the only food in the world that needed a court to decide what it is. Not because it is complicated, but because it is in the wrong place and everyone had agreed to stop mentioning it. A vegetable that is a fruit, on a plate, unasked, in the savoury course, for a hundred and thirty-three years.
The Bureau does not want the tomato reclassified. The Bureau wants it declared. One mark on the menu, one line under it — the same ask, made for the same reason: nothing should arrive at a plate that was never on the list.
And if anyone tells you the tomato is a fruit and therefore fine, remind them that a court settled that question by looking at dinner, and that the answer it gave was vegetable, and that neither answer had anybody's consent in it.
file 2012-P1 · the concession · pico de gallo
The Bureau concedes one.
Pico de gallo is a dish genuinely made of tomato, and if you take the tomato out of it there is nothing left. One dish. The register says one. An argument with a concession in it cannot be dismissed — and a fruit is allowed to be one.
